An application for Canadian permanent residence may face delays if an immigration officer believes the applicant could already be a Canadian citizen.
Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) can place a permanent residence application on hold if there are reasons to believe the applicant may qualify for citizenship through a Canadian parent, grandparent, great-grandparent, or another earlier ancestor.
According to Briannah Dale, a senior communications adviser at IRCC, the department cannot confirm how many permanent residence applications have been paused because applicants may also qualify for Canadian citizenship.
The issue follows Bill C-3, which changed Canada’s Citizenship Act and came into effect on December 15, 2025.
The law removed the previous first-generation limit on citizenship by descent. As a result, people born outside Canada before December 15, 2025, may qualify for citizenship if they can prove an unbroken line of descent from a Canadian ancestor.
This change may affect Americans and other foreign nationals with Canadian family roots who are already applying for permanent residence.
Canadian law does not allow someone to hold Canadian citizenship and permanent resident status at the same time. Therefore, an immigration officer may pause a permanent residence application if there are strong reasons to believe the applicant is already a citizen.
IRCC has also clarified that an applicant does not need to have submitted a citizenship certificate application for an officer to review their possible citizenship status.
Note: Having a Canadian grandparent or great-grandparent does not automatically make someone a Canadian citizen. The Canadian ancestor must have held citizenship when the next generation was born, and the family line must meet the legal requirements without any breaks.
What Happens If Someone Applies For Both Permanent Residence And Citizenship By Descent?
According to Dale, when a person applies for proof of Canadian citizenship while a permanent residence application is also under review, IRCC places the permanent residence application on hold until the citizenship application is assessed.
If IRCC confirms the person’s citizenship, the permanent residence application will be considered withdrawn. If the department does not confirm citizenship, the permanent residence application will return to its original place in the queue and continue through the assessment process.
An explanation from IRCC’s Immigration Representatives Mailbox, shared publicly by immigration lawyer Steven Meurrens, also outlines the department’s position.
The response explains that Canadian law recognizes individuals with valid citizenship claims as Canadian citizens. Therefore, they cannot apply for immigration documents reserved for foreign nationals, including a permanent resident visa.
However, the mailbox response describes a slightly different procedure. It states that IRCC may contact applicants with pending permanent residence applications and ask them to withdraw their immigration application and submit an application for a citizenship certificate. In adoption cases, an adoption application may be required instead.
The response also advises people who believe they may qualify for citizenship under the new rules to apply for a citizenship certificate.
The mailbox provides general guidance and does not address individual cases. The IRCC mailbox does not clarify whether officers will pause or withdraw every affected permanent residence application. The exact approach may depend on the officer reviewing the case.
Comparing Citizenship Certificate And Permanent Residence Wait Times
Receiving proof of Canadian citizenship can take significantly longer. Some permanent residence applications have much shorter wait times.
As of October 2026, IRCC listed the estimated wait for a proof of citizenship application at 34 months. This estimate can change as the department receives and reviews applications.
By comparison, spousal sponsorship applications submitted from outside Canada and outside Quebec had an estimated wait of about 18 months. Applications through the Express Entry system for skilled workers had an estimated wait of around seven months.
These differences may make permanent residence appear to be a quicker option. However, an applicant who already qualifies as a Canadian citizen by descent cannot choose permanent residence instead.
A citizenship certificate serves a different purpose from a permanent residence document. It confirms that the applicant is already a Canadian citizen under the law.
People who obtain citizenship by descent do not need to meet a physical presence requirement in Canada, take a citizenship test, or attend an oath ceremony. These requirements generally apply to foreign nationals who become eligible for citizenship after obtaining permanent resident status.
Dale has also clarified that people who already hold permanent resident status will not lose it simply because they are waiting for a decision on their citizenship certificate application.
What Should Applicants With Pending PR Applications Do?
Applicants who suspect they have a Canadian ancestor may benefit from checking their citizenship eligibility before beginning or continuing a permanent residence application.
Confirming citizenship status first can help avoid spending time and money on an immigration application that may not be necessary or available to them.
If IRCC determines that an applicant does not qualify for citizenship, the permanent residence application can return to its original place in the queue and continue.
Applicants should therefore review their family history and gather relevant documents before deciding which application to submit.
Could Someone Already Be A Canadian Citizen By Descent?
Individuals who are uncertain about their citizenship status can begin by researching their family history.
A parent, grandparent, or earlier ancestor born in a Canadian province or territory may provide an important starting point. However, the applicant must establish the citizenship status of each generation in the family line.
Some family history details may also suggest a possible French-Canadian connection. These include relatives who spoke French at home, French surnames, or family roots in parts of New England.
Such details do not prove citizenship eligibility. They can, however, help applicants identify which side of their family may have a connection to Canada and where further research may be useful.
Speaking with the oldest living relatives can also help. Family members may remember where earlier generations lived, whether an ancestor moved from Canada, or where important family records were kept.
Ultimately, a citizenship claim depends on supporting documents. Applicants may need records that establish their relationship to each generation and prove the Canadian ancestor’s citizenship status.
It is also important to understand which other family members may qualify. Children born before December 15, 2025, may also be Canadian citizens by descent if they meet the applicable requirements. Each eligible child must submit a separate application for a citizenship certificate.
A spouse does not automatically become a Canadian citizen through marriage. Citizenship by descent is based on family lineage or adoption, not on being married to a Canadian citizen.
For children born or adopted on or after December 15, 2025, an additional rule applies. The Canadian parent must show at least 1,095 days, or three years, of physical presence in Canada before the child’s birth or adoption.
Checking the family connection, confirming the citizenship status of each generation, and collecting the required documents can help applicants understand whether citizenship by descent is an option before pursuing permanent residence.
Explore your pathway to move to Canada with Immigtoronto. Our team of skilled RCICs offers customized immigration solutions, ensuring a trustworthy and professional process. Contact us at [email protected].



